|
Martin Lehmann - 27 February 2001
Few people are aware that WA's shopping regulations, some of the most
restrictive in the world, are race-based.
The laws had their genesis in the competition posed by Chinese shopkeepers to
the colonial shop owners in the 1890's.
The colonials, incensed that the Chinese shopkeepers kept working after they
stopped work at dusk to down a few pink gins, lobbied the government of the day
to bring in the original restrictions under what became known as the Early
Closing Act.
Speaking to the 1897 bill, MLC Frederick Crowder backed the shopkeepers'
ploy of using the state to outlaw competition, when he said: "The true
reason for bringing forward this bill is the desire of the large shopkeepers to
stifle competition and stop the Chinese trading."
"Asiatics no doubt should not compete with Europeans."
Other speakers referred to the "unfair" competition posed by the
Chinese because could "live on a bowl of rice a day and the smell of an
oily rag".
The original law has evolved into a bureaucratic nightmare of regulations. The law does
not apply above the 26th parallel nor does it apply to areas designated as
holiday resorts. Another regulation allows shops to open if they have not more
than ten staff in the shop.
Hence while most Perth shops are forced to close on Sunday, shops in Perth's
southern suburb of Rockingham have unrestricted trading because it is a
designated holiday area.
The result today of this mess is that a small number of traders,
particularly independent supermarket owners, are making a healthy profit out of
a government-enforced monopoly.
This vocal minority has engaged some high-profile lobbyists to trumpet how
they will be flattened by the "big boys" if their monopoly is taken
away.
But Coles and Woolworths have between them around 740,000 shareholders with
less than 5,000 shares (the so-called mum and dad investors) while on the other
hand the independent supermarkets are quietly
being bought out by a group of wealthy business migrants.
In a superb irony one of Kenya's richest businessmen, an
"Asiatic", now owns five Perth supermarkets that enjoy a government
licence to trade on Sundays, while two public companies, largely owned by
ordinary Australian workers via superannuation funds and direct investment, face
heavy penalties if they open their doors. All thanks to the Early Closing Act
that sought to restrict the "Asiatics" from trading while favouring
the locals.
|